Directed by Shinji Ishihara
Produced by C2C
Streaming on HIDIVE
The isekai genre has existed in some form or another for decades, though the current model was cemented a decade ago by the runaway success of Sword Art Online. It’s funny, though, that I’ve seen debates on whether or not SAO even qualifies as a portal fantasy; they don’t even technically go to other worlds.
But that only speaks to how far the genre has come. In the past ten years since SAO first aired, we have been absolutely flooded with fantasy anime about overpowered characters in other worlds that operate on RPG logic. It has given us some of the best anime ever made, my own favorite Re:Zero included, and delivered a few hundred half-baked duds as well.
The genre of light novel isekai adaptations has become oversaturated to the point of bursting, as authors trip over themselves to produce new and weirder stories than ever before. It’s a competitive market, and if your main character isn’t getting reincarnated as a vending machine in another world, sorry, but the readers don’t care.
It is with great trepidation that I introduce you all to the anime Reincarnated as a Sword. I will struggle to even tell you a basic plot synopsis, because the title has already done a better job than I ever could.
If you have a strong drink handy, head on down to this magical world where multiple corporate executives had give their stamp of approval to an anime where a guy dies, becomes a sword, and joins a loli catgirl on her quest to…end slavery, I think?
Reincarnated as a Sword does not have the most intricate of plots. See, light novel authors have pretty much figured out that their entire audience knows the deal already: the main character is either a high school dropout or single salaryman as well as an otaku who dies after getting his first kiss from the bumper of our old friend, Truck-kun.
Since we know all that, we skip past that boring stuff like characterization. I mean, it isn’t like the guy who literally codified the hero’s journey also established that we should see the hero in the normal world to contextualize their actions in the other world. So, we start with our unnamed protagonist getting hit by a car and dying, and waking up as a sword on a pedestal.
Before going any further, let me add a side note that treating the conventions of your genre as so well-worn that you don’t bother explaining them, all while not doing anything to innovate them, is extremely lazy writing.
The first roadblock to the sword’s new life is that he’s an inanimate object, so the author cheats around his own premise by giving the sword a full magic loadout. Thanks to that, he’s able to maneuver his way into a grinding session for the better part of the first episode.
I don’t need to tell you how unbelievably boring this is. It was kind of novel when That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime did it, but that was four years ago, and that series actually has decent character writing. You got to learn about Rimuru before his death, and he was developed through his relationship with Veldora. Here, we get to see a sword goof around killing knock-off Dragon Quest enemies for ten minutes.
Then we have Fran, the aforementioned catgirl, who escapes slavery after finding the sword, who she names Shishou. That’s it, actually. The whole first episode kind of just wastes its time on tired old RPG tropes, barely setting up Fran and Shishou meeting at the end of it, and a stupid in medias res beginning that offers nothing of importance to the story.
The plot and characters of Reincarnated as a Sword are what happens when a writer has an idea with absolutely none of the skill to follow through on their execution. The emotion is forced, I don’t care about either of them, and they waste so much time in the first episode that it’s a miracle I got through it.
I might hope that its terrible bland writing would be redeemed if Reincarnated as a Sword was at least pretty to look at. For what it’s worth, there is some solid direction involved, and the fight choreography isn’t terrible. It’s actually rather interesting, considering Shishou can’t fight like a normal person.
The music is quite good, but if you read my review of Eminence in the Shadow, stuff like that just makes the rest of the series’ flaws stand out worse. It just leaves you thinking, “Why is this grand music playing over a scene where barely anything is happening?”
The character design is just atrocious. Cool swords are a staple of anime, so I have to ask why our main character is the ugliest weapon I’ve seen in the medium. Fran’s just sort of plain and while they really try to make her cute, her design is so uninspired that it completely misses. And the side characters?
Anime like Princess Connect! Re:Dive have some objectively ugly and bland character design for unimportant characters, but the main difference here is that Priconn is based on a gacha game, so every important character is gorgeous. The cast of Reincarnated as a Sword looks ugly because, well, the show is ugly.
I foreshadowed this moment when I talked about Eminence in the Shadow, which was a bad anime, but one that I could reasonably see an audience for. I do not know the person who likes Reincarnated as a Sword.
If we’re talking about isekai fans, then there are so many better options. It’s not self-aware enough to be a good parody like Konosuba or The Hero is Overpowered but Overly Cautious. It’s not written well-enough to engage anyone looking for something more than surface level enjoyment. It’s not even good for popcorn anime, because there are so many better isekai and fantasy anime for that.
Just about every idea that Reincarnated as a Sword has to offer was already done much better in That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime. The protagonist becoming an unconventional fantasy mainstay, grinding his way up to being OP, only works when you have a fun, likable cast of characters. There’s no tension in the story, so what do you have left?
And I’m not even holding up Slime Isekai as this tentpole of the genre; it’s just a bit of light-hearted fantasy anime. I just fail to understand how anyone could enjoy an anime whose very purpose has already been exceeded in every way by an anime that came out years prior.
Heck, just start looking at the isekai tag on MyAnimeList and you’ll probably find fifteen shows that are equally derivative, but at least manage to be entertaining.
It’s not fun writing these kinds of reviews. When I talk about a hilarious dumpster fire like Girlfriend Girlfriend or a schlocky edgefest like Eminence in the Shadow, I have the hope that the creators of these anime are aware that they’re not making Casablanca. There is a place in anime for bad and nonsensical shows to be enjoyed for what they are, but Reincarnated as a Sword has no place.
It is ludicrous to the point of parody while taking itself as seriously as a show with triple the emotional stakes. It presents ludicrous concepts side by side with jarring dark turns.
The main character is a sword who saves a slave catgirl while all the other slaves get brutally murdered by a monster while the masters run away. Is this a comedy? Is this horror? I don’t know, and I don’t think the writers know.
So, yeah, just give this crap a Boring Egregious and I’ll try to talk about an anime I like more next week. It’s not very good either, but like in a way that doesn’t make me want to throw myself into the sea. Until next time, thanks for reading.
|Egregious||Reincarnated as a Sword||Eminence in the Shadow|
5 responses to “Reincarnated as a Sword Review: Double-Edged Garbage”
I’m not sure if that was your intention, but this post was an excellent roast of Reincarnated as a Sword. I actually started cracking up a little! You certainly have a way with words! And you do have a point, it was kind of a disappointing anime. What I find most unfortunate is that it had so much potential, but due to poor writing, it just kind of fell flat. Like the idea that the main character appeared in a fantasy world as a sword, that’s pretty cool! But one of the first things the anime does is make being a sword inconsequential. It would have actually been better if the MC didn’t have the ability to move around on its own, than there would be a real need for another character to help the MC, so cast building would have been more natural and less forced.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Agreed. I’m sorry it was not fun to write, but this was a very entertaining read for a show I’d never even consider watching.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I gotta say, as someone who loves this series, and has followed it since it was barely a LN, this made me sad to read…but I kinda get it. I think this series’ greatest strength is its world building, but frankly that only makes it harder to adapt into an anime. You don’t know where Fran comes from, or what Amanda has done, or what’s happening to teacher, and that definitely cheapens the feel of the anime, but at the same time you can only accelerate the story so much before it stops making any sense.
I would honestly just call this an ‘adventure’ over a comedy or horror, again because it’s not so simple a story that you can pigeonhole it that easily. There’s comedy, but it also doesn’t shy away from more mature themes.
I still love it though, and I’m hoping S2 is even better. Feels wrong to categorize it as egregious boring considering they give things like redo of a healer time slots, but to each their own.
Ok I read through your opinion about Reincarnated as a sword and let me just say this. Some of y’all are just going too far with these comments and these high standards(probably not with just this show, but all isekais) for how the story should play out. Anime in general talks about the different perspectives and possibilities that can take place. A dude being Reincarnated as a sword and going on a journey with a black cat to evolve and bring honor back to her people. Now how many stories are actually like that. The show doesn’t reveal everything but that what others seasons are for people. Not every isekai made have to explain everything in the beginning, and if that the case why should they all be made that way anyway. Not everything has to be done a certain way, if that was the cases most anime like these would be predictable and played out. Cut these people some slack man and stop expecting them to meet your high ass standards. The fact they didn’t reveal everything means that they’re more to come. Reincarnated as a sword is a amazing show with it own unique charm. Oh yeah the guy that started this, you made one major comparing Reincarnated as a Sword to Eminence in Shadow. I mean what the fucked dude. Anyone who seen the moment of Eminence in Shadow knows it a great show. That where you went wrong. CID/Shadow unlike Fran/Teacher is never in a situation where he isn’t in control. Even when he put himself in a vulnerable situation he pretty easily get out of it. Every anime is unique in it own way which is what makes them worth watching. I mean there something for everyone. The way you comment shows you don’t understand the show at all or your expecting too much. Maybe you should take that boot out your ass, lower your damned standards, or better yet make your own show cause Reincarnated as a Sword is obviously not meant for you.
I sometimes wonder why Google recommend me to read those kinds of trash.